Monday, April 23, 2007

It lives...but...

So, does the Monster have a soul? A conscience?

13 comments:

Gerald said...

I don't know about a soul, but i do believe the monster has a conscience. The monster is able to make its own decisions and act for itself, but was never taught right from wrong since Frankenstein abandoned it.

erica said...

As of right now I think the book is leading us to believe that the monster doesn't have a soul because lacks judgement, but I also believe that further on in the book we will be able to see that he does have a soul...?

All day...every day said...

A soul is not something that can be given by man....therefore Frankenstein has no soul. However, a conscience is something from within yourself. It is merely a test of morality.

Anonymous said...

bump...

chandra said...

I think the monster does have a conscience. He has to learn everything for himself. He talks to Frankenstein and tells him how he felt when Frankenstein abandoned him. He definitely knows what is going on.

Brittany said...

i believe that the monster has a conscience, and he knows what is happening, he may not know why or how but he knows

Mikey B. said...

I think the Monster has a conscience but it's the same type of conscience that a baby has except the baby conscience is in a monster body....the monster still has to learn what is good and bad just like a baby learns in the beginning of his life.

Jeremy L. Pledger said...

I once read a story about a gorilla that was taught sign language and had a very large vocabulary and would have conversations with its keepers. when they asked the gorilla what death was it said deep sleep, but it also said it was sad when another gorilla died. they concluded that the gorilla had some form of ethical view towards the world but not nearly moral awareness of most 6 years to which its mind was compared. i think the monster is kind of like this, he has some moral awareness, but not exactly a soul.

Tino Is Cool said...

I agree with Jeremy completely

Anonymous said...

I think the real question is do we have souls?

Mrs. C said...

The question is can you exist without one? What is life and what is death?
Enjoy.

Johnny said...

I think the monster doesnt have a soul because a man cant give you a soul. He does have a conscience because he acts alone and makes decisions for himself.

D' Rock said...

The monster has a conscience... but a soul you can not get by a scientist. the monster does a lot of decisions by himself